"No Down Payments - No Contingency Agreements"

Atlas Roofing & Siding

Should a New Roof Have Exposed Nails?

Date

Should a New Roof Have Exposed Nails?

You just paid for a new roof. The shingles look clean, the color is right, and the yard has finally been cleared of the last stray wrapper and piece of debris.

Then you notice a shiny metal dot near the edge of the roof.

At first, it may not look like much. But once you realize it is a nail head, the question is obvious: Should a new roof have exposed nails?

Most of the time, you should not see bare roofing nails scattered across the visible surface of an asphalt shingle roof. The shingles are installed in overlapping rows specifically so the fasteners underneath stay covered. A few finishing fasteners may be used in certain places, but they should be handled according to the roofing manufacturer’s installation instructions.

So if you are seeing bright nail heads throughout a roof that was just installed, it is worth asking the contractor to take another look.

Why Are Roofing Nails Supposed to Stay Covered?

A shingle roof works by shedding water.

Each course overlaps the one below it, and the nails are normally driven into the part of the shingle that will be covered by the next row. Once the roof is complete, those fasteners are protected instead of sitting directly in the rain, snow, and sun.

That matters because every roofing nail creates a penetration through the shingle.

When the nail is in the right place, the overlapping system protects it. When it is driven too low or left visible, that protection is missing.

The roof might not leak tomorrow. In fact, it may look perfectly fine for quite a while.

The concern is what happens after years of Ohio weather.

What Happens to an Exposed Nail Over Time?

Metal and roofing materials do not stay completely still.

Summer heat warms the shingles. Winter temperatures cause materials to contract. Rain, snow, ice, and wind keep working on the roof year after year.

An exposed nail head can eventually corrode. The shingle around the fastener may also move slightly with temperature changes.

That can create a small opening around the nail.

Water does not need much room to get through. A tiny opening that goes unnoticed from the ground can eventually let moisture reach the roof deck below.

That is why exposed nails are not simply a cosmetic concern.

Are There Any Places Where Nails Might Be Visible?

Yes, which is why spotting one nail does not automatically mean the entire roof was installed incorrectly.

The top of the roof is one example.

Ridge-cap shingles overlap one another just like the shingles on the main roof, but eventually the installer reaches the final cap. There is no next piece available to cover the last set of fasteners.

Depending on the shingle system, those finishing nails may be installed and then covered with the proper roofing cement or another manufacturer-approved material.

That is very different from leaving bare metal exposed.

The location tells you a lot.

A properly sealed finishing nail near a ridge is one thing. Several uncovered nails in the middle of the roof slope are something else.

What Does a Misplaced Roofing Nail Look Like?

Sometimes homeowners notice what roofers call a “shiner.”

It gets that name because sunlight reflects off the metal and makes the nail stand out from the darker roofing material.

A shiner may happen when a nail is driven below the correct nailing area. Because it sits too low, the shingle above does not cover it.

You may be able to see it from the driveway when the light hits the roof just right.

Other nail problems are harder to see.

A fastener may be driven too high, angled incorrectly, or left slightly raised beneath another shingle. In those situations, there may not be a shiny nail head visible from the ground at all.

The shingle may simply sit unevenly or begin lifting later.

Is One Exposed Nail a Big Deal?

It’s true that one nail is not the same as dozens of them. Still, a newly installed roof should not leave you wondering whether water can work its way through an obvious fastener hole, so a single exposed nail is a big deal.

If you notice one exposed nail, document it and call the roofing company to request an inspection and repair. That is usually a much better move than waiting to see whether a leak develops.

Should You Fix the Nail Yourself?

Probably not. Sure, covering a nail with whatever tube of caulk happens to be in the garage may seem like a simple fix, but roofing materials are designed to work together in a specific way.

The wrong sealant may not last for very long. More importantly, the exposed nail might be a sign that the shingle itself was fastened incorrectly. You could cover the shiny part and still leave the original installation problem underneath, but that might not work out well in the long run.

However, you should always call a roofing contractor first before trying to fix anything yourself. Walking on a roof is dangerous, especially if you are not used to working at height or on sloped surfaces.

A New Roof Should Not Look Half-Finished

A new roof involves thousands of nails, but most of those nails should disappear beneath the shingles once the job is complete.

So, should a new roof have exposed nails? In the main field of an asphalt shingle roof, bare fasteners generally should not be visible. Certain finishing points may involve exposed fasteners, but they should be treated according to the roofing system’s installation requirements.

If you see shiny nail heads across a new roof, do not assume they are harmless.

Take a picture. Call the roofer. Ask for an inspection.

Atlas Roofing & Siding provides roof installation, repair, maintenance, and re-roofing services throughout Central Ohio. The company has served homeowners and businesses in the area since 2003 and works with customers from the initial inspection through project completion.

If you are concerned about exposed nails, uneven shingles, leaks, or another roofing problem, contact Atlas Roofing & Siding to schedule an estimate.

Get A Free Estimate

Have a question about any of our services? Give us a call at (614) 766-8100 for a Free Estimate.